Douglas Development hopes to open a new hotel on the Richardson Olmsted campus in June and is set to sign an agreement to begin phased development of all 13 buildings at the national historic site.
Savarino Cos., which had an agreement to develop two of the buildings at the east end of the site, agreed to step aside to allow Douglas Jemal to take on the entire project and qualify for historic tax credits. .
The rush to get work done at the Richardson Hotel and Conference Center led to a stop work order issued Friday by the city’s Permits and Inspections Department, at the request of the Buffalo Preservation Board. The city’s action halts a covered porch-like structure being built above the hotel’s entrance until further examinations are carried out.
Paul Hojnacki, president of the Richardson Olmsted Campus, said the reopening of the hotel and the prospect of Jemal developing the entire 463,000 square foot site is a lifeline for the property.
“We didn’t have anyone locally, nationally or globally interested in developing these properties without us investing $20 million or more,” Hojnacki said.
People also read…
“Douglas Development came forward and said we’ll tackle this project, and we’ll tackle anything,” he said. “He’s the only one who wants to invest his own money to save these buildings.”
Hojnacki estimated the level of investment needed to rehabilitate the stone and brick buildings at a minimum of $50–70 million.
“There are many buildings in an incredible state of disrepair,” he said of the brick buildings to the west of the towers.
The buildings, designed by Henry Hobson Richardson in a style known as Richardsonian Romanesque, and the grounds, by Frederick Law Olmsted and Calvert Vaux, opened in 1880 as the Buffalo State Asylum for the Insane.
The property had stood empty since 1974 before the Henry Urban Resort’s conference center opened in April 2017 in three buildings centered around the site’s striking red sandstone towers. The hotel closed in February 2021, partly victim of the pandemic.
The hotel’s opening was the centerpiece of one of the largest historic restoration projects in the United States and has received numerous architectural preservation and design awards and citations. In 2004, the state approved $76.5 million to revive the colossal-sized site, with an additional $10 million raised through grants and fundraising and $16 million in tax credits. state and federal.
But with a pandemic and a slowdown in travel to Canada, no developer was interested in taking over the empty hotel until Jemal stepped forward, Hojnacki said.
The hotel’s lease took effect Jan. 1 and is essentially the same as that given to INNVest Lodging Services, which operated Hotel Henry, Hojacki said.
“We couldn’t get anyone else to take on those terms,” he said. “He’s paying rent and utility costs and is still months away from having an income.”
Jemal said his company was working on the hotel’s interior and planned to bring back the building’s original wallpaper discovered by his team.
“My target date is June,” Jemal said.
But just to be sure, the developer said they don’t plan weddings because they don’t want to disappoint anyone if it takes longer than expected.
“We will open when we get it right,” he said.
Jemal also revealed that he refunded $250,000 to newlyweds whose deposits were not honored in 2021 by INNVest Lodging Services after the Henry Hotel was abruptly closed. Jemal made a public offer to help them at the time after reading about their plight.
The issue surrounding the porte-cochere being built at the entrance to the hotel is complicated, said Gwen Howard, president of the Buffalo Preservation Board.
The city’s Permits and Inspections Department inadvertently issued Douglas Development a building permit because the hotel’s address, 444 Forest Ave., is different from 400 Forest Ave. for the rest of the site.
This address would have first triggered the need for a review by the Buffalo Preservation Board.
Paul Millstein, vice president of Douglas Development, appeared before the board on Thursday to seek approval for the porch-like structure.
Instead, Millstein was told that work needed to be halted and the project filed so that local, state, and federal agencies could review the project.
The State Historic Preservation Office, in conjunction with the National Parks Service, will assess the Porte Cochere to ensure that it meets a 50-year preservation clause that relates to work on the Towers Building, as well as the requirements of historical historical tax credits used on buildings. The Preservation Board will consider its overall impact on the local monument.
“I’ll be the first person to say that the layers of the overall legislation because of these covenants and tax credits and everything else is a lot, and it might be hard to navigate,” Howard said.
“I think the message we got was that Douglas Development wants to do all the right things and follow the rules, whether or not they understand the complexity and the layers of all those rules,” she said. “I don’t think anyone wants to stand in the way of Mr. Jemal’s success in running the hotel. And we are grateful for his investment.”
Jemal said “it was something that slipped through the cracks” and he wants to do what is necessary.
“We are working on it and we will work on it appropriately,” Jemal said.
“It’s an extremely difficult property, and it’s not a marathon, it’s a triathlon, and all we want is for it to be a success at the end of the day,” he said. -he declares. “Everything we’re supposed to do, we’ll do.”
Catherine Amdur, the city’s permit and inspection commissioner, issued her stop-work order on Friday after first allowing the porte cochere to stabilize. This allowed the six steel columns, installed vertically and bolted to concrete foundations, to be attached to the roof frame, bringing the project closer to completion.
The design team who rehabilitated the hotel buildings sent a letter to the Preservation Council and Douglas Development, objecting to the scale of the porte-cochere and its visual impact on the entrance and view on the towers.
“The proposed porte-cochere threatens to diminish the design and undermine the integrity of historic buildings,” the letter read. “We are not against any future changes to the site, but ask that they be designed with sensitivity and follow the community awareness and public process for which this place has become known.”
Signatories to the letter include Deborah Berke, the design architect; Peter Flynn, executive architect; and architects Barbara Campagna and Kelly Hayes McAlonie, who co-chaired the design committee of Richardson Center Corp.
Mark Sommer covers preservation, development, waterfront, culture and more. He is also a former arts editor for The News.